I am a huge fan of Cory Doctorow’s and largely agree with his analysis and conclusions. The forces of capitalism that create the greatest accomplishments of our civilization get ground down by systems optimizing for a quantum of return on an arbitrary timescale dictated by a market.
However, as those who know me know, I don’t tend to curse outside of karaoke sessions or periods of extreme absurdity, so I’ve found it hard to reference him when speaking and writing. (I have no problem with others cursing; it’s just not part of my personal vernacular.)
I would like to suggest a new word, which as of this posting has zero hits on Google, Enstuppification: the stupidity of being penny-wise and pound-foolish, and putting a quick buck ahead of long-term profits and gain. It’s stupid! Not just crappy, as Cory’s word emphasizes! As Larry Fink said in 2019,
Commitment to a long-term approach is more important than ever—the global landscape is increasingly fragile and, as a result, susceptible to short-term behavior by corporations and governments alike.
— Larry Fink
It also taps into the definitions of stupefaction, “the state of being stunned, bewildered, or made dull and unable to think clearly (from the verb stupefy)”, and stultification, “the act of causing someone or something to appear foolish, absurd, or intellectually stunted.”
So “enstuppification” is an homage to Cory Doctorow (with the double P) and Larry Fink, who are both correct and rarely spoken in the same sentence. Pronounce it en-stoop-ification. And let’s not forget the teachings of Stewart Brand and the Long Now Foundation. (It’s Sunday, so a good time to revisit Stewart’s TED Talks from 02008 on the 10,000-year clock and 02009 on dense cities, nuclear, GMOs, and geoengineering.)
Two examples from my life of promoting long-termism are spreading Open Source through WordPress and Automattic selling a 100-year plan. These are meant to fight enstuppification, yet even within those projects it creeps up and catches us sometimes. In Open Source it shows up as bikeshedding; in companies it shows up as people trying to maximize a bonus.
Show me the incentive, I’ll show you the outcome.
— Charlie Munger
(That quote is an apocryphal aphorism; Charlie has never been recorded saying it exactly, but listen to The Psychology of Human Misjudgment on YouTube or read more on Farnam Street.)
This is also why I don’t really feel comfortable being against “private equity,” as 99.999% of my net worth and value creation for society have been in equities that are privately held, not on the public markets. Words matter, and when we say “the problem is private equity,” we’re missing that everything we enjoy in life, from an iPhone to automobile transportation, once had an investor take a chance on somebody.
I think people get so nerdsniped by blockchains because the solution to short-termism isn’t to report less frequently, which would help good companies like Berkshire but be taken advantage of by bad actors. It’s more transparency and real-time reporting. Markets should be 24/7 because reality is. But perhaps there’s some wisdom in them shutting down, so we can all rest.
Anyway, write “enstuppification” to someone and right-click to add it to your dictionary. 😊